Faith-Filled Cozy Christmas Fiction for the Holidays
These stories offer a refreshing mix of tones and settings—some nostalgic and traditional, others lighthearted and modern—but all of them capture the goodness of the season. You’ll find gentle romances, heartfelt family themes, and characters learning to open their hearts to hope again. Historical readers will enjoy stepping back into quieter times filled with charm and seasonal warmth, while contemporary fans will appreciate stories that feel relatable and real, with just the right touch of holiday sparkle.
What ties these books together is the way they slow you down and invite you into a world where kindness matters, relationships are mended, and love has room to grow. Whether the pages take you to a cozy small town, a countryside manor, or a snowy little community preparing for Christmas, each story offers its own sense of comfort.
These novels make wonderful companions throughout the holiday season—perfect for evenings when you want something uplifting, or mornings when you’re easing into a busy day with a warm cup in hand. If you’re looking for books that blend faith, gentle storytelling, and the timeless hope of Christmas, this list has plenty of heartwarming favorites to choose from.
A Sea View Christmas by Julie Klassen
Regency Historical Romance
Sarah Summers once discouraged the interest of a handsome Scottish widower, but his return stirs up regret. Meanwhile, her younger sister Georgiana anticipates the Christmas of her dreams, not expecting to be surprised by young love. Does the festive romance of a Sea View Christmas hold the key to a happily-ever-after for both sisters?
Once Upon a Christmas Carol by Melody Carlson
Romantic Dickens Retelling
Carol Langstrom hates Christmas. Being born on December 25th and growing up in a dysfunctional home has turned her into a modern-day Scrooge. Her plan: to escape this holiday in the Bahamas—but storms reroute her flight to Michigan. Amid the snowy landscape, she gets stuck on her aunt’s farm and rediscovers a different kind of Christmas—one wrapped in love.
On a Midnight Clear by Tracie Peterson, Misty M. Beller, and Karen Witemyer
Western Historical Romance
Tracie Peterson, Misty M. Beller, and Karen Witemeyer come together in this festive Christmas novella collection inspired by the nativity story. Faith, hope, and romance abound, from a stable outside a stage stop in Nebraska Territory, to a stormy shepherd’s field in Wyoming, to a small university in Texas hosting three visiting wise men.
The Christmas House by Beverly Lewis
Amish Romance
Liz Lantz runs a buggy tour business in Hickory Hollow, assisted by a handsome young Amish man during the Christmas season. Her Englisher neighbor’s lavishly decorated house has brought the quiet community unwanted attention, and Liz is determined to find a way to bring harmony to Hickory Hollow in time for Christmas.
The Christmas Catch by Toni Shiloh
Sports Romance
After a career-ending injury, NFL wide receiver Jahleel Walker returns to his hometown for Christmas, where he runs into his high-school sweetheart, Bebe Gordon. The connection between them is still strong, but Jahleel has no plans to stay, and Bebe can’t risk him leaving again. Will they take a chance on love or let life sideline them at Christmas?
The Christmas Tree Farm by Melody Carlson
Small Town Romance
In order to save the family Christmas tree farm that her sister is determined to sell, Madison McDowell will have to focus her efforts—and grapple with her old boyfriend who owns the neighboring farms and has plans of his own—if she’s to succeed. After all, the farm deserves a second chance. And perhaps love does too.
Christmas at Sugar Plum Manor by Roseanna M. White
Nutcracker-Inspired Edwardian-Era Historical Romance
Plumford Manor is destined to go to Lady Mariah’s estranged childhood friend, a distant relative of her stepfather. When he arrives at the start of the Christmas season, their friendship re-ignites, despite the strong attentions of a certain Danish Lord, and Mariah begins to hope for something more this Christmas season.
Meddling with Mistletoe by Liz Johnson
Small Town Romance
Whitney Garrett and Daniel Franklin find themselves back at the Red Door Inn at Christmastime. Both have bright futures ahead and don’t expect to stay on Prince Edward Island for good. But a little holiday spirit, Christmas pie, and meddlesome matchmaking might just change their plans.
An Ivy Hill Christmas by Julie Klassen
Regency Historical Romance
Haunted by an old secret and the shadows of his past, gentleman Richard Brockwell prefers to stay away from Ivy Hill—until his mother threatens to stop funding his carefree life unless he returns for Christmas. Will Christmastime in Ivy Hill, with all of its divine hope, unforeseen surprises, and unexpected romantic encounters, work its magic in his heart?
All’s Fair in Love and Christmas by Sarah Monzon
Contemporary Romance
Mackenzie Graham’s work crush, Jeremy Fletcher, has barely noticed her—until they compete for the same much-needed promotion. But winning has less to do with work performance and everything to do with showing the most Christmas spirit. As their yuletide duel progresses, it might be more than a job they risk losing.
You Make it Feel Like Christmas by Toni Shiloh
Contemporary Romance
Starr Lewis returns home for the holidays, jobless and single, to attend her sister’s wedding to Starr’s ex-boyfriend. But when her brother’s best friend offers to go with her to the wedding activities and she gives his struggling Christmas shop a makeover, she wonders if the holidays could bring her a love to keep all year long.
A Royal Christmas by Melody Carlson
Contemporary Romance
No-nonsense law student Adelaide Smith doesn’t believe in fairytales. But when she learns she’s the daughter of King Maximillian V, the ruler of a small European principality, she’s swept into a world filled with family mysteries, royal jealousies, and the possibility of her own happily ever after.
Happy Reading,
Club31 Team
